If you could choose to be apart of a group or discourse, what would you choose to be? Would you choose to be apart of another race? In "Goin' Gangsta, Chosin' Cholita," teenagers talk about how they have chosen to change their identity, or rather, their image, but, in reality, these teens are white. My question is, though, that if discourse heavily relies upon being recognized as a specific discourse, are these teens really apart of these discourses.
For instance in the movie, "Save the Last Dance," the main character, Sara, moves to New York to live with her father, and attends a prodominately African American school. As the movie progresses, she starts to hang out more often with African American teenagers who act, speak, and dress in an urban fashion. The more she hangs out with them, and relates to them, she begins to pick up some of their speach, action, and dress patterns. Even so, when she starts to date an African American guy, her guise does not hold true to some of the other African American characters who feel she should not date him because she is white.
The issue here is that the other characters would not accept her as being "Black." Although she could dress like them, speak like them, attend their school and clubs, and later even dance like them, she was still white in their eyes. Her progression into Urban Society, though shows how one's environment can affect the discourse that a person chooses. Surrounded by African Americans, she chose to try and fit in even though she never lost her true identity.
Ergo, are the teens in "Goin' Gangsta, Chosin' Cholita" ever really gansta or cholita? Personally, I don't think so because these discorses are related to specific groups within races. Instead, I think that these teens have created a different discourse all together.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I liked how you related to the movie "Save the Last Dance". What you said is very true about how she did almost everything like the African-Americans in the movie, but still she was viewed as the "white girl".
ReplyDeleteYou could also relate it to the movie "Bring It On Again". Im not sure if you have seen this movie, but in the end the "white girl" is finally accepted into the African-American and Hispanic discourse community. So to answer your question, yes I believe the teens in "Goin' Gangsta, Chosin' Cholita" can eventually be gangsta or cholita if that is what they really want to be.
First of all, I love this movie. Second, I think that you made a great connection to our discourse unit, by using this movie as an example. I'm not sure how many have seen it, but I know that everyone who has seen would most likely agree that she still doesn't fit in, no matter how hard she tries to change in order to be like them. At that one part, even her "best" new friend, turns on her saying that everyone is mad at her because she is the "white girl" and is trying to take one of they only decent "blakc guys" that are available to those women. She says that Sara is taking one of "their men."
ReplyDeleteThis shows that no matter how hard she tries to fit in, even those closest to her, still recognize her as being a type of outsider.